I contemplated and resisted having a golf lessons for many years. But eventually I did. I took lessons to change my swing. Why? I felt like I’d reached a point in my golfing journey where improving would be difficult unless I embraced change. More specifically, through the help of a professional coach. My goal at the time (before lessons) was to be a sub bogey handicapper. I took advantage of a discounted offer for a series of lessons with a PGA coach at my local range (Oulton Hall, West Yorkshire, UK). Below are the topics I’ll touch on, along with a summary that answers the questions, “Should I have changed my swing?”, as well as the positives and negatives of having Golf lessons.
- Making a draw my standard shot shape
- Generate rotation with a stable stance
- Is a wristy swing a good thing?
- Compressing the golf ball
- Should I have changed my swing?
Would you like your shot shape to be a Draw?
This was the first question the PGA coach asked – it was more of a suggestion. The simple reason to focus on a draw was to learn and adjust to one shot shape introducing some consistency to my play. I have an in-to-out club path (if you’re not sure what club path is click here), which persists to this day. This favors a draw as opposed to a fade – the latter would push shots further right. Logical right? Choice made, “Yes” was my answer.
Adjusting Face Angle
To obtain a draw your face angle must be to the left of your club path (the opposite for a lefty; see “How to fade and draw the golf ball”). We looked at videos of Brooks Koepka and compared his take away position to mine. At about a half swing (club parallel to the ground) my club face was open towards the sky, Brooks was closed pointing down towards the ground. Learning to close the face wasn’t easy, but I persisted.
Adjusting Grip
Changing my grip was a choice I made, a reluctant one, but one I felt I needed to do to help generate a more consistent draw, something I struggled with at first. I made my grip stronger.
Despite the reluctance to change my grip, in the end it wasn’t as bad as I thought. It does feel very strange to begin with, it did for me. But with persistence the grip change felt natural. More than this, I gained a lot from the process. For a while I struggled to fade with my new strong grip. So, I experimented with grip changes for different shots on the range, one after the other. Although I still find drawing the ball easier, I’m now able to change my grip to help generate a fade without too much discomfort. Does it always work? No, but hey, pros don’t always execute their shot shape either.
Generating Rotation with a Stable Stance
Lifting the back Foot
I had a distinct lack of follow-through and rotation. What did I need this for? The task was simple, lift my right foot through transition into impact, allowing my hips to rotate. The aim was to have my belt buckle face the target – you’ve heard this before right?
This took some getting used to and I’m still not convinced I rotate enough (June 2022). But, on the odd occasion when I don’t lift my right foot at all, I feel static and awkward, and if I still hit an okay shot, I feel I’ve got away with it (it is now October 2024 and I don’t even think about this anymore, I just do it).
Wristy Swing = Less Control
We started with a review of my swing – PGA coach and partner in crime, Trakman. It became immediately apparent that I had a wristy swing. This gave me power, high ball flight, lots of spin (occasionally) and an unpredictable shot shape, i.e., sometimes left, sometimes right, often interchangeable.
I was advised that generating power through the wrists can be very effective, but not necessarily at the level I was at; above bogey Handicap at the time. So, “I got the power“, but I’m not generating it in an effective way (wristy) and ball flight inconsistent.
Compression Ball Striking
The final element to help me with better ball striking, with a draw, was to introduce compression ball striking. At impact position, your shaft should be leaning forward (about 10 degrees, you may hear others quote differently), and the divot you create should be after the ball. The idea is that you’re hitting down on the ball at impact, the shaft lean means you’ll be hitting the sweet spot of the club face at impact.
I really wanted to nail this, since I had a habit of hitting the ball fat (divot before the ball), which became obvious in cooler months when the ground was wet, soft and less forgiving; in summer the hard surface, like a range mat, gives some forgiveness meaning you hit the ball fat less often, hiding the issue.
For me this has probably been the hardest thing to install into my swing. Why? Because my Wristy swing wanted to return and run free. This requires me not to use my wrists, instead making them feel rather stiff, forcing them forward at impact. As with all changes, it felt incredibly uncomfortable at first. But the benefits seem huge. When I get it right. I get a lower more penetrating ball flight; the ball goes straighter and I get more distance than I had with Wild Wristy. This is still something I work on pretty much every range session. Specifically, I use punch shots – 1/2 and 3/4 swings – which is how the coaching session started, maintaining wrists forward at impact. Whenever things go awry now, I revert to punch shots. I’ve also seen video clips of Tommy Fleetwood talking about how he transitioned to using punch shots as his standard swing, because he and the coach found them more consistent.
Should I have changed my swing?
My simply answer is yes, I believe it was a good move for me. I clearly had a lot to change. Some changes were easier to make than others. Should you? I’ve outlined some positives and negatives that I hope will help you.
Negatives
Lets start with the negatives:
- I had some of the lessons in what felt like quick succession (six over a three-month period), in hindsight that doesn’t seem that long at all. However, this felt like I had a lot of changes to make with little time to practice between. By the end I was confused, sometimes frustrated, and I didn’t know what to concentrate on. I was trying to do everything at once and didn’t know what I had worked on successfully.
- In future, I’ll either spread the lessons out more, or take the odd lesson to focus on one aspect of my swing at a time.
- It wasn’t easy. From my experience, don’t expect all changes to stick. Although some of mine did. Straightening my back leg stuck immediately, although it does slip every now and then.
- Old habits may return. Continue to reinforce with range sessions, reflect and persist with reminders of what you’re trying to do. Head back for another lesson to measure progress.
Positives
The process of changing my swing with a professional PGA coach taught me so much and I am a student of the game and love leaning:
- Better understanding of my swing and good technique:
- Shaft lean and compression at impact
- Closed face and stronger grip to aid persistent Draw
- Braced knees, wider stance, straight back leg on take away, raise back foot to aid rotation through impact.
- There’s plenty more I haven’t mentioned I’m sure…
- More tools – changing wrists to help produce fades or draws, use of punch shots for better accuracy.
- Feel more in control and happy with the outcome – I’ve gained yardage across all my clubs from technique alone
- Commitment to shaft lean has led to better shots out of semi-rough and rough.
- Learned to commit and trust the changes made will result in a more consistent swing and ball striking; shaft lean at impact is the clearest example of this.
Has it led to direct improvement in my game? Yes, without doubt. In three years my handicap dropped 6 shots.
In summary – Is my swing change journey at an end?
I very much doubt it, and writing this blog made me realise how much was covered in so few lessons. I do feel these are the biggest and hardest changes I’ll ever make. I’m glad I made the decision to embrace change, working with a PGA coach. I love the journey of learning and improving, my hunger for both continue. I hope you feel the same if you decide to take a similar journey. Let me know how you get on if you do in the comments below.
With thanks to PGA Coach Scott McGovern.
Leave a Reply